Was Baby Jesus an Illegal Immigrant? Fact, Fiction, and the Call to Mercy
The Holy Family were law-abiding subjects of the Roman Empire who complied with the decrees of the state.
Every Christmas season, a familiar argument resurfaces: the idea that Jesus, Mary, and Joseph were “undocumented immigrants” or “illegal aliens” during their flight to Egypt. Some use this narrative to justify modern illegal immigration, suggesting that to oppose it is to condemn the Holy Family itself.
Can you imagine people trying to use baby Jesus during the Christmas season to justify illegal immigration? Yes, that’s how desperate some people can be to fit the Bible into a modern political mold. But was the baby from Bethlehem an illegal immigrant?
The answer is a definitive NO.
1. Migration Within a Single Empire
When Joseph and Mary fled to Egypt to escape Herod’s decree, they were not crossing a modern international border. At the time, both Judea and Egypt were provinces under the Roman Empire.
Moving from Bethlehem to Egypt was a move within the same legal jurisdiction. Crossing from one area to another did not violate any immigration laws because they remained within the boundaries of the empire that governed them.
“And he rose and took the child and his mother by night and departed to Egypt and remained there until the death of Herod.” — Matthew 2:14–15 (ESV)
2. Compliance with Civil Authority
The biblical narrative highlights the family’s commitment to following the law. We see this clearly in the events leading up to Jesus’ birth:
The Decree: Joseph and Mary traveled to Bethlehem specifically to comply with a legal order from the highest civil authority, Caesar Augustus.
Legal Registration: They did NOT evade civil authorities, nor did they reject legal obligations. They traveled a difficult distance specifically to legally register and fulfill their civic duties. They complied with them!
“In those days a decree went out from Caesar Augustus that all the world should be registered... And all went to be registered, each to his own town.” — Luke 2:1, 3 (ESV)
3. Addressing the Critique: “Who is My Neighbor?”
Some might ask, as the lawyer once asked Jesus, “And who is my neighbor?” They might argue that focusing on “legality” is the same spirit that Jesus rebuked when He quoted Hosea 6:6:
“For I desire steadfast love and not sacrifice, the knowledge of God rather than burnt offerings.” — Hosea 6:6 (ESV)
The argument is often made: Was not the Samaritan an enemy? Was Ruth an “illegal”? Had you known what this means, “I desire mercy not sacrifice,” you would not have condemned the innocent!
While these are vital questions regarding our personal heart for the vulnerable, they do not change the historical facts of the Nativity:
The Samaritan: Jesus used the Good Samaritan to define who we should love (mercy), but the Samaritan was traveling on a public road, not violating a national border or a census decree.
Ruth: Ruth was a “sojourner,” a status specifically defined and protected within the Law of Moses. She followed the legal and cultural customs of the time to be redeemed. She was not an “illegal” bypasser of the law; she was a faithful convert who found refuge within the legal framework provided by God.
The Adult Jesus: Even at His trial, the Roman governor Pontius Pilate stated three times, “I find no guilt in him” (John 18:38). Jesus was never a criminal; He was an innocent man subjection to the law.
4. The Higher Standard
The New Testament consistently teaches that believers are to be subject to the laws of the land. Joseph and Mary modeled this behavior, even under the threat of persecution.
“Let every person be subject to the governing authorities. For there is no authority except from God, and those that exist have been instituted by God.” — Romans 13:1 (ESV)
“Be subject for the Lord’s sake to every human institution, whether it be to the emperor as supreme, or to governors...” — 1 Peter 2:13–14 (ESV)
The Bottom Line: Truth, Not Just Narrative
As we celebrate the birth of Christ, we must resist the urge to project our modern political debates onto the ancient text of the Gospels. Desperation to find biblical “loopholes” for current policy issues often leads to the distortion of the very Word we claim to follow.
The historical and biblical evidence is clear: Jesus was not an “illegal” immigrant. From His first breath to His last, He lived in subjection to the governing authorities of His time. We are indeed called to be like the Good Samaritan—to have hearts full of mercy for the vulnerable—but Christian mercy is never an excuse for historical dishonesty.
We can love our neighbor and seek justice for the immigrant without falsely labeling the King of Kings as a lawbreaker. Let us honor the Savior by telling His story accurately.
Reference